🍂 November Treats Pre-Orders
Homemade pies, cheesecakes, fresh breads & rolls and seasonal sweets — baked fresh for Thanksgiving.
🦃 Thanksgiving orders due by Sunday, Nov 15.
Pickup Thursday–Sunday, plus Thanksgiving Pick Up Day Wed Nov 25 (12–5 PM). In store only.
Apple Pie
Double crust pie made with farm fresh apples from Columbus Discovery Orchard with the perfect blend of sugar and spice.
Cream Pie
Buttery crust filled with homemade custard and either fresh bananas or coconut, topped with homemade whipped cream.
Cherry Pie
Double crust pie made with Door County cherries.
Lemon Meringue Pie
Freshly squeezed lemons and fresh zest make a sweet but tart filling, topped with a large pile of meringue, perfectly browned.
Pumpkin Pie
Single crust filled with a smooth spicy pumpkin filling and topped with homemade whipped cream. A Thanksgiving staple!
Pecan Pie
An American classic single crust filled with dark, gooey custard with pecans and brown sugar.
Classic Cheesecake
Our creamy rich classic cheesecake topped with our homemade whipped cream border.
Cherry Cheesecake
Our creamy rich classic cheesecake topped with our homemade cherry filling made with Door County cherries.
Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake
Our classic cheesecake swirled with homemade raspberry filling and topped with homemade whipped cream.
Turtle Cheesecake
Our classic cheesecake with a little chocolate added and a thick layer of caramel and pecans on the bottom. Homemade whipped cream, caramel and pecans for garnish.
Pumpkin Chai Cheesecake
A perfectly pumpkin cheesecake with some chai flavors sprinkled in, topped with homemade whipped cream and a little spice sprinkle.
Sourdough
Classic Sourdough, slowly fermented and perfect for every meal! 28oz round loaf.
Dinner Rolls
Perfectly soft dinner rolls great smothered in butter or stuffed with turkey. Pop these in the oven just before serving.
Pumpkin Bread
Great for breakfast on Thanksgiving morning or a little something with your coffee. A great sweet bread filled with pumpkin and cinnamon and dusted with powdered sugar.
Cinnamon Rolls
Our most popular item in the bakery! Gooey cinnamon and brown sugar rolled up in a soft and sweet dough and frosted with homemade cream cheese frosting.
Apple Crisp
Farm fresh apples coated in cinnamon and sugar, topped with an oatmeal streusel. Sold in an 8" pan.
Baked Apple Cider Donuts
All your favorite apple flavors baked into a delicious apple cider donut and topped with a cinnamon sugar mix.
Pumpkin Bars
Moist cake-like bars full of pumpkin and cinnamon, topped with cream cheese frosting. Sold in an 8" pan.
Sample Box
Made with a variety of items we have made that day; great for sampling for an event or wedding, or just for yourself. Special requests: call or stop by the bakery.
Gift Card
Order a digital gift card for Fireman's Mercantile & Bakery — perfect for the holidays.
Available amounts:
- $10
- $25
- $50
- $100